Language
Development in Children
Development of Speech
The development
of speech has been associated with myelination of Broca's area within the
brain, hence delays in myelination due to deficiencies, in vitamin B12, iron and
vitamin D are associated with delayed development of speech.
Depending upon the combination of deficiencies, there will
potentially be a different developmental outcome, thus contributing to the
"Spectrum" of conditions that constitute ASD
This development is intimately tied to the development of cognitive function.
The development of cognitive functions has been linked to maturation (e.g., the
onset of myelination) in brain fiber tracts responsible for these functions (
Thomason
and
Thompson, 2011).
Studies have shown that language performance in children is related to white matter maturation. The phase
of rapid vocabulary development from 18 months onward is accompanied by a
concomitant rapid myelination phase in brain regions supporting language,
specifically temporal and frontal regions in the left hemisphere of the brain.
The most rapid rate of development of receptive and expressive language occurs
between 18 adn 60 months of age (Pujol
et al., 2006; Cheng
et al., 2018).
Speech discrimination, an aspect of receptive language, has been shown to be
predictive of later overall language development by 6 months (Tsao
et al., 2004).
-
Makes sounds. At 4-6 months the child start to laugh and giggle.
-
At around 5
months the child begins to make repetitive "babbling" noises, such a bub-bub-bub,
ma, or da
-
Talking: By age 1, the child should be able to use 1.2 words, at at 1-2, this
increases to 5-20 words.
-
At age 2-3 the vocabulary has increased to around 450 words, and the child is
able to construct short sentences.
-
By age 4 the vocabulary has increased to around 1000 words, and
-
By age 5 or 6, the child should have mastered their native tongue.
Development of Receptive
language. Receptive language is the ability to understand language.
The "Language" may be verbal, or may be physical in nature (ie understands
non-verbal clues)..
Receptive language develops after the child starts to speak
and involves
-
Develops
paying attention to conversation,
-
good eye/face contact, and
-
good literacy, and
-
the use of expressive language.
Often children with ASD have poor
receptive language. They may have difficulty paying attention to conversation,
poor eye/face contact, and have poor literacy, and expressive language. see
Receptive Language (understanding words and language) - Kid Sense Child
Development and
Receptive language development in children aged 0-5 years | Child Development
Institute
Development of Expressive
language.
Expressive language is the use of words, sentences, gestures and writing to
convey meaning and messages to others. This function appears to be
concentrated in Broca's region of the brain, and myelination of Broca's region
precedes the development of speech (Walker 1981).
Expressive language skills include:
-
Repeating new words heard from other people - Echolalia.
-
Being able to label objects in the environment,
-
Describe actions and events,
-
Put words together in sentences,
-
Use grammar correctly (e.g. “I had a drink” not “Me drinked”), retell a story,
-
Answer questions and
-
Write or relate a short story.
-
Children develop from up to 50 words at 12 months to around 5000 words at 6
years of age
People with poor expressive language skills
-
Echolalia after age 3, is common in autism
-
Have difficulty naming items and objects.
-
Cannot link together words or uses sentences that are shorter than others of
the same age.
-
Use sentences that sound immature for their age.
-
Use ‘jargon’ (made up words) in speech.
-
Produce sentences that are ‘muddled’ (i.e. words in wrong order, lots of stops
and starts, and a lack of flow).
-
Are not understood by unfamiliar people.
-
Have difficulty finding the right words to use in conversation or when
describing or explaining something.
-
Have trouble retelling a story.
-
Have difficulty writing paragraphs and stories.
Expressive Language (Using Words and Language) - Kid Sense Child Development
Improvement in expressive language can be achieved by
-
Playing with the child on a regular basis and talking about what they are
doing
-
Talk to the child continuously through the day, about what you are doing,
where you are going to go to, what you are going to do there, and repeat what
you have just done
-
Increase the interaction by turning off background noises and distractions.
-
Talk face-to-face with the child who should mirror your facial expressions and
process of language creation
-
Expand the language that they use, ie add words to what they are saying hence
"Dog" becomes "Big dog" or Big black dog", etc.
-
Read lots of books together with the child, particularly on subjects that they
are interested in. Ask them which books that they want to read, and talk about
the story or the pictures in the book.
-
Repeat back to the child words or phrases that they have said incorrectly, but
correct the sentence.
Understanding the process of development of Speech.
Analogies to the development of speech. The first would be when a person is
outside, particularly at sun-rise. The person hears all these noises. Now to the
untrained ear, you can't tell what bird is what, but you can select out a
kookaburra, Channel-billed cuckoo, rainbow lorikeet, and an Indian Minor plus
you can tell a car going by, and you can selectively listen to a conversation in
the street. Your mind has been able to sort all of those noises and identify
them. You could also think of those puzzles that have all the jumbled letters in
them and you have to find words in amongst the jumbled words. This is of course
easier if you are given the words that you have to find. I "liken" the two
examples to a child trying to understand speech. Hence to develop receptive
language, the child has to be able to "selectively" pull out language from all
the noises around him/her/ At first the child has to be able to follow one voice
- probably the mother - who the child would be most familiar with. Then the
child has to try to separate all the sounds coming from the mother into
individual words, phrases and sentences. This requires lots of processing.
Imagine trying to build a machine to do it. In this case the machine is the
child's brain. Once the child has "recognized" that there is something special
in the "language" it has to be able to Comprehend the different words,
Understand how small changes in the words can change the meaning. Distinguish
between the different speech sounds. Understand how important the order of the
words are in a sentence.
Encouraging the Development
Firstly one needs to work out where in the analogy is the problem, and then fix
that. Simplistically one could start by drawing attention to one particular
sound, so that the child is able to focus on a sound. One could say, "where is
that sound coming from?". E could also follow a sound, so that the child sort of
tracks it. By tracking the sound the child has to focus on the one sound. E can
do it with pictures of animals in books as well. "What sound does a duck make -
Qvack, Qvack, Qvack". The mother duck said Qvack, Qvack, Qvack and all of the
little ducks came back. The get the child to make the sound of the duck. So the
child has some receptive language - ie what or where is the sound, and some
expressive language in that the child has to mimic the sound.
Nutritional Deficiencies and Delayed Development of Speech in Autism
Myelination is essential for the development of speech, and delays in
myelination are associated with neurodevelopmental retardation (Webb 2017).
Myelination is in turn controlled by the action of melatonin and functional
vitamin D (1,25dihydroxyvitamin D) on neuronal stem cells and the
differentiation into myelin-producing oligodendrocytes.
Production of Melatonin is critically dependent upon functional
B12 sufficiency, and lack of melatonin is associated with poor sleep, poor gut
health and food intolerance, and lack of myelination, thereby causing delays in
ability to sit, crawl, stand, walk and delays in potty training. Myelination is
essential for the development of speech, and delays in myelination are
associated with neurodevelopmental retardation. Brain myelination at 7 months
predicts later language development (Corrigan et al, 2022). Language exposure in
children contributes to myelination, with the increases in myelination being
associated with increased exposure to language (Fabia et al, 2022; Huber et al,
2023); Pujol et al, 2006)
Production of melatonin is essential for stimulating the differentiation of
neuronal stem cells into myelin-producing oligodendrocytes. Production of
melatonin, requires active B12. Hence if active B12 levels are low during this
early period, myelination will be delayed and so too will the development of
speech.
Production of the intracellular energy transfer molecule,
creatine is also dependent upon functional B12 sufficiency and lack of creatine
alone causes many of the symptoms of autism and will contribute to hypotonia
(floppy baby syndrome), and neurodevelopmental delays (Incecik et al, 2010).
An essential part of speech production is the development of memory, and
deficiency in the gaseous neurotransmitter, hydrogen sulphide has been
associated with loss of memory in conditions such as Alzheimer's disease. (He et
al, 2019). Production of hydrogen sulphide is dependent upon functional methyl
B12 sufficiency, and lack of functional methyl B12 would in turn result in
reduced producion of hydrogen sulphide and further delay in the development of
speech.
Education and Speech Delay
One of the mainstays of successful teaching is achievement and reward. Thus, it
is the reward that the person gets from learning that drives learning, not the
actual process of learning. Normally these "rewards" entail increased transient
production of dopamine and serotonin.
When a rewarding event occurs, dopamine levels increase, which enhances
motivation to repeat the behavior leading to that reward. This is a
problem in functional vitamin B12 deficiency, particularly in Autism as
the children have extremely high levels of dopamine (often higher than any drug
addict), and serotonin (levels 200 times normal are not uncommon). This then can
mean that it is very hard to motivate the children to learn, particularly to
learn reading and writing (Russell-Jones 2022). Thus, neurotypical children
often learn early speech and language skills through close contact with their
parents, and repeated social interaction, however, children with autism have
problems with social contact and are not as comfortable to even be in the
position to learn. This is re-enforced by the perceived difficulty in doing so.
One of the problems with using external rewards to motivate the child is that
they may rely on external validation of their worth, rather than develop their
own sense of self-worth.
|
NT |
ASD |
HVA |
1.68 +/- 1.38 |
5.72 +/- 3.2 |
VMA |
1.035 +/- 0.51 |
2.86 +/- 1.53 |
Comparison of the dopamine break-down products, HVA and VMA between neurotypical
children (NT) and those with ASD.
Accompanying the increase in the levels of dopamine, one would expect a
reduction in the expression of the dopamine receptors, meaning that even if the
children do get a reward from their behaviour the absence of the receptor will
greatly diminish their response. A similar phenomenon is found in obese people
where the level of dopamine receptors is reduced, and so they get less reward
from eating, and hence would eat more (Wang et al, 2001). In addition, several
studies have shown a correlation between obesity and elevated homocysteine,
indicative of functional B12 deficiency (Al
Fatly et al, 2024; Wang etal, 2023; 2021).
Reduction in brain stimulation to decrease the reward seeking brain stimulation
can be achieved by over-production of dopamine or by using
dopamine-antagonizing drugs, which blocked the effects of dopamine, or through
destroying the reward pathways.
Overcoming Speech Delay in children with autism
It would appear that in order to do this effectively there are two essential and
complementary strategies that need to be employed
1. The functional vitamin B12 deficiency needs to be resolved, This would then
lead to increased myelination, increased production of creatine for energy,
increased production of hydrogen sulphide, and hence greater memory retention.
The increased methyl B12 then would decrease the production of dopamine, and so
increase the learning-reward stimulus
2. Increased use of techniques that stimulate the child to learn to speak,
including increased involvement of the parents and teachers with the child,
increased excitement/stimulus/reward by the parents and children as they perform
the task with the child, and increased emphasis on the rewards aspect of
learning.
Examples can be found at
Speech
Sounds by Age (and How to Teach Them)
There are lots of memorable examples in kids books, such as Fee, Fi, Fo, Fum in
Jack and the Beanstalk.
The Great, Grey, Green, Greasy Limpopo River of Rudyard Kipling fame
Around the ragged rocks the rugged rascal ran.
The silver snake slithered on the sunny hillside
Shrek, the sheep who escaped shearing for seven years
Larry, the lounge lizard, lay along the ledge
Make it fun.
Other Ongoing problems for Children with Autism
Vitamin B12 deficiency is strongly associated with the ongoing
mental problems observed in many children with autism, including anxiety (20%),
sleep-wake disorders (13%), depressive disorders (11%), obsessive-compulsive
disorder (9%), bipolar disorders (5%) and schizophrenia spectrum disorders (4%)
References
-
CHECKLIST
Milestone Checklists (cdc.gov)
-
https://www.healthline.com/health/childrens-health/stages-of-child-development#18-months-2-years
-
Nickel and Gu 2018 Regulation of Central Nervous System
Myelination in Higher Brain Functions
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5859868/pdf/NP2018-6436453.pdf
-
Walker LC. The Ontogeny of the Neural Substrate for Language. J Hum Evol. 1981
Jul;10(5):429-441. doi: 10.1016/s0047-2484(81)80007-3. PMID: 35296125; PMCID:
PMC8923642.
-
Bauman, M., & Kemper, T. L. (1985). Histoanatomic observations of the brain in
early infantile autism. Neurology, 35(6),
866–874. https://doi.org/10.1212/wnl.35.6.866
-
Ozgen etal, 2011
J. Autism Dev. Disord. 41,
23-31
-
Developmental Milestones: 3 Months - HealthyChildren.org
-
DevelopmentalMilestonesEYLFandNQS.pdf (acecqa.gov.au)
-
Georgieff MK. The
importance of iron deficiency in pregnancy on fetal, neonatal, and infant
neurodevelopmental outcomes. Int
J Gynecol Obstet. 2023a; 162(Suppl.
2): 83-88.
doi:10.1002/ijgo.14951
-
Ataide R, Fielding K, Pasricha S-R, Bennett C. Iron
deficiency, pregnancy, and neonatal development. Int
J Gynecol Obstet. 2023; 162(Suppl.
2): 14-22.
doi:10.1002/ijgo.14944
-
Georgieff MK. Maternal
gestational iron status and infant haematological and neurodevelopmental
outcomes. BJOG. 2023b; 130(Suppl.
3): 92–98. https://doi.org/10.1111/1471-0528.17612
-
Prue H. Hart, Robyn
M. Lucas, John
P. Walsh, Graeme
R. Zosky, Andrew
J.O. Whitehouse, Kun
Zhu, Karina
L. Allen, Merci
M. Kusel, Denise
Anderson, Jenny
A. Mountain; Vitamin D in Fetal Development: Findings From a Birth Cohort
Study. Pediatrics January
2015; 135 (1): e167–e173. 10.1542/peds.2014-1860
-
Andrew J. O. Whitehouse, Barbara
J. Holt, Michael
Serralha, Patrick
G. Holt, Merci
M. H. Kusel, Prue
H. Hart; Maternal Serum Vitamin D Levels During Pregnancy and Offspring
Neurocognitive Development. Pediatrics March
2012; 129 (3): 485–493.
-
Eyles DW. Vitamin D: Brain and Behavior. JBMR Plus. 2020 Oct 18;5(1):e10419.
doi: 10.1002/jbm4.10419. PMID: 33553986; PMCID: PMC7839822.
-
Incecik F, Hergüner MO, Altunbaşak S, Leblebisatan G. Neurologic findings of
nutritional vitamin B12 deficiency in children. Turk J Pediatr. 2010
Jan-Feb;52(1):17-21. PMID: 20402062.
-
Ljungblad UW, Astrup H, Mørkrid L, Hager HB, Lindberg M, Eklund EA,
Bjørke-Monsen AL, Rootwelt T, Tangeraas T. Breastfed Infants With Spells,
Tremor, or Irritability: Rule Out Vitamin B12 Deficiency. Pediatr Neurol. 2022
Jun;131:4-12. doi: 10.1016/j.pediatrneurol.2022.03.003. Epub 2022 Mar 21. PMID:
35439713.
-
Avino TA, Barger N, Vargas MV, Carlson EL, Amaral DG, Bauman MD, Schumann CM.
Neuron numbers increase in the human amygdala from birth to adulthood, but not
in autism. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2018 Apr 3;115(14):3710-3715. doi:
10.1073/pnas.1801912115. Epub 2018 Mar 20. PMID: 29559529; PMCID: PMC5889677.
Fabia et al. 2023 Language exposure and brain myelination in early
development. J. Neurosciene7, 4279-2490
Neva M. Corrigan, Vasily L. Yarnykh, Elizabeth Huber, T. Christina Zhao,
Patricia K. Kuhl, Brain myelination at 7 months of age predicts later language
development, NeuroImage, Volume 263, 2022, 119641,
Language Experience
during Infancy Predicts White Matter Myelination at Age 2 Years | Journal of
Neuroscience
Myelination of language-related areas in the developing brain | Neurology
Expressive Language (Using Words and Language) - Kid Sense Child Development
Improving Receptive Language | Talkshop Speech Pathology
Wanda G. Webb PhD, CCC-SLP, in Neurology
for the Speech-Language Pathologist (Sixth Edition),
2017
Myelin sheath: Myelination, function, clinical relations | Kenhub
Russell-Jones 2022
B12 deficiency in Autism
The Dark Side of Rewards, Part 1: Why Incentives Do More Harm Than Good in the
Classroom - Opening Doors to Safer and More Inclusive Schools
Wang GJ, Volkow ND, Logan J, Pappas NR, Wong CT, Zhu W, Netusil N, Fowler JS.
Brain dopamine and obesity. Lancet. 2001 Feb 3;357(9253):354-7. doi:
10.1016/s0140-6736(00)03643-6. PMID: 11210998.
Al Fatly M, Mulder MT, Roeters van Lennep J, Blom HJ, Berk KAC. The effect of
diet-induced weight loss on circulating homocysteine levels in people with
obesity and type 2 diabetes. Nutr J. 2024 Jan 3;23(1):2. doi:
10.1186/s12937-023-00908-y. PMID: 38167024; PMCID: PMC10763019.
Wang X, Peng H, Xia C, Zhou Y, Shen L, Cheng X, Yang C, Yang Y, Long L.
Association of B vitamin intake and total homocysteine levels with all-cause
and cause-specific mortality in central obesity. Nutrition. 2023
Dec;116:112189. doi: 10.1016/j.nut.2023.112189. Epub 2023 Aug 7. PMID:
37689015.
He JT, Li H, Yang L, Mao CY. Role of hydrogen sulfide in cognitive deficits:
Evidences and mechanisms. Eur J Pharmacol. 2019 Apr 15;849:146-153. doi:
10.1016/j.ejphar.2019.01.072. Epub 2019 Feb 2. PMID: 30721700.
Wang J, You D, Wang H, Yang Y, Zhang D, Lv J, Luo S, Liao R, Ma L. Association
between homocysteine and obesity: A meta-analysis. J Evid Based Med. 2021
Sep;14(3):208-217. doi: 10.1111/jebm.12412. Epub 2020 Nov 3. PMID: 33145936.
Brain
Reward System
Ekhtiari, H., & Paulus, M. (2016). Neuroscience
for Addiction Medicine: From Prevention to Rehabilitation-Methods and
Interventions.
Elsevier.
Copyright © 2014 B12 Oils. All Rights Reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written
permission is prohibited